{"authors":[{"id":"orcid_______::12997ba278ac7a74395b3bd80eb070ab","fullName":"Marcus N. Boon","name":"Marcus N.","surname":"Boon","rank":1,"pid":{"id":{"scheme":"orcid","value":"0000-0002-9288-1292"},"provenance":null}},{"id":null,"fullName":"Lorenzo Cassola","name":"Lorenzo","surname":"Cassola","rank":2,"pid":null},{"id":"orcid_______::75ee132a2ae1c0f8b55596d6274d513e","fullName":"Hans-Christian Ruiz Euler","name":"Hans-Christian","surname":"Ruiz Euler","rank":3,"pid":{"id":{"scheme":"orcid","value":"0000-0002-4401-2623"},"provenance":null}},{"id":"orcid_______::6bf980a1139bb75477be631743b85b02","fullName":"Tao Chen","name":"Tao","surname":"Chen","rank":4,"pid":{"id":{"scheme":"orcid","value":"0000-0002-6768-3630"},"provenance":null}},{"id":null,"fullName":"Bram van de Ven","name":"Bram","surname":"van de Ven","rank":5,"pid":null},{"id":null,"fullName":"Unai Alegre Ibarra","name":"Unai","surname":"Alegre Ibarra","rank":6,"pid":null},{"id":"orcid_______::dd9d3bfc4189ce6f03f7d5e96321ed40","fullName":"Peter A. Bobbert","name":"Peter A.","surname":"Bobbert","rank":7,"pid":{"id":{"scheme":"orcid","value":"0000-0001-7780-7062"},"provenance":null}},{"id":"orcid_______::1f417dda6326eabe83cea4df5799b5d0","fullName":"Wilfred G. van der Wiel","name":"Wilfred G.","surname":"van der Wiel","rank":8,"pid":{"id":{"scheme":"orcid","value":"0000-0002-3479-8853"},"provenance":null}}],"openAccessColor":"gold","publiclyFunded":false,"eoscIfGuidelines":null,"type":"publication","language":{"code":"eng","label":"English"},"countries":[{"code":"NL","label":"Netherlands","provenance":null}],"subjects":[{"subject":{"scheme":"FOS","value":"0301 basic medicine"},"provenance":null},{"subject":{"scheme":"keyword","value":"FOS: Computer and information sciences"},"provenance":null},{"subject":{"scheme":"FOS","value":"0303 health sciences"},"provenance":null},{"subject":{"scheme":"keyword","value":"Computer Science - Machine Learning"},"provenance":null},{"subject":{"scheme":"keyword","value":"cs.LG"},"provenance":null},{"subject":{"scheme":"keyword","value":"Computer Science - Neural and Evolutionary Computing"},"provenance":null},{"subject":{"scheme":"keyword","value":"Computer Science - Emerging Technologies"},"provenance":null},{"subject":{"scheme":"keyword","value":"Article"},"provenance":null},{"subject":{"scheme":"keyword","value":"Machine Learning (cs.LG)"},"provenance":null},{"subject":{"scheme":"FOS","value":"03 medical and health sciences"},"provenance":null},{"subject":{"scheme":"keyword","value":"cs.ET"},"provenance":null},{"subject":{"scheme":"keyword","value":"Emerging Technologies (cs.ET)"},"provenance":null},{"subject":{"scheme":"keyword","value":"cs.NE"},"provenance":null},{"subject":{"scheme":"keyword","value":"Neural and Evolutionary Computing (cs.NE)"},"provenance":null}],"mainTitle":"Gradient descent in materia through homodyne gradient extraction","subTitle":null,"descriptions":["<jats:title>Abstract</jats:title>                   <jats:p>Deep learning, a multilayered neural-network approach inspired by the brain, has revolutionized machine learning. Its success relies on backpropagation, which computes gradients of a loss function for use in gradient descent. However, digital implementations are energy hungry, with power demands limiting many applications. This has motivated specialized hardware, from neuromorphic CMOS and photonic tensor cores to unconventional material-based systems. Learning in such systems, for example via artificial evolution, equilibrium propagation, or surrogate modelling, is typically complicated and slow. Here, we demonstrate a simple gradient-extraction method based on homodyne detection, enabling gradient descent directly in physical systems without the need for an analytical description. By perturbing parameters with sinusoidal waveforms at distinct frequencies, we robustly obtain gradient information in a scalable manner. We illustrate the method in reconfigurable nonlinear-processing units and argue for broad applicability. Homodyne gradient extraction can in principle be fully implemented in materia, facilitating autonomously learning material systems.</jats:p>"],"publicationDate":"2025-11-21","publisher":"Springer Science and Business Media LLC","embargoEndDate":"2021-05-01","sources":["Crossref","Nat Commun"],"formats":null,"contributors":null,"coverages":null,"bestAccessRight":{"code":"c_abf2","label":"OPEN","scheme":"http://vocabularies.coar-repositories.org/documentation/access_rights/"},"container":{"name":"Nature Communications","issnPrinted":null,"issnOnline":"2041-1723","issnLinking":null,"ep":null,"iss":null,"sp":null,"vol":"16","edition":null,"conferencePlace":null,"conferenceDate":null},"documentationUrls":null,"codeRepositoryUrl":null,"programmingLanguage":null,"contactPeople":null,"contactGroups":null,"tools":null,"size":null,"version":null,"geoLocations":null,"id":"doi_dedup___::58e8f4042da3347d55ee21bec72dabd5","originalIds":["65155","10.1038/s41467-025-65155-7","50|doiboost____|4ebb7e79fcf0c832751cd83e045e46cd","50|datacite____::58e8f4042da3347d55ee21bec72dabd5","10.48550/arxiv.2105.11233","od_______267::e1b3fce42a0b9d22ddcc92a66fe4264c","41271705","PMC12639101","50|od_______267::e1b3fce42a0b9d22ddcc92a66fe4264c","oai:pubmedcentral.nih.gov:12639101","oai:arXiv.org:2105.11233","50|od________18::3e4b7f01445510d5159e18162c1a0fbd","oai:pure.tue.nl:openaire_cris_publications/df37e49a-8cfc-4206-9cf4-ec2a5a4e8680","50|dris___01180::0f28968029a1cac1bb09ff00ab5e1c01","oai:ris.utwente.nl:openaire_cris_publications/468078f0-c95d-4ab5-b62b-459cc25b5b9a","50|dris___02403::6bb67b2a08e2abae465a212a908f2b29","50|dris___02403::d9fbe7e8729279f0d257e2e571ad771f","oai:ris.utwente.nl:openaire_cris_publications/b09c172e-87a3-408f-aeb2-f3519cac3ba6"],"pids":[{"scheme":"doi","value":"10.1038/s41467-025-65155-7"},{"scheme":"doi","value":"10.48550/arxiv.2105.11233"},{"scheme":"pmid","value":"41271705"},{"scheme":"pmc","value":"PMC12639101"},{"scheme":"arXiv","value":"2105.11233"}],"dateOfCollection":null,"lastUpdateTimeStamp":null,"indicators":{"citationImpact":{"citationCount":0.0,"influence":2.1921431E-9,"popularity":2.2912217E-9,"impulse":0.0,"citationClass":"C5","influenceClass":"C5","impulseClass":"C5","popularityClass":"C5"}},"projects":[{"id":"dfgf________::1e5e62235d094afd01cd56e65112fc63","code":"unidentified","acronym":null,"title":"unidentified","funder":"Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft","pids":null},{"id":"nwo_________::67563d4d3fff945e7e854b1b92050bdb","code":"680-91-114","acronym":null,"title":"Evolutionary Computing in Nanomaterial Networks","funder":"Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research (NWO)","pids":null},{"id":"nwo_________::2b348ef45c33b63733388ee1f906b8a2","code":"16237","acronym":null,"title":"Nanomaterial Networks for Artificial Intelligence in the Automotive Industry: NANO(AI)2","funder":"Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research (NWO)","pids":null},{"id":"corda_____he::850b2bd09d4e5fdac05a4164365ce14d","code":"101046878","acronym":"HYBRAIN","title":"Hybrid electronic-photonic architectures for brain-inspired computing","funder":"European Commission","pids":[{"scheme":"doi","value":"10.3030/101046878"}]}],"organizations":[{"legalName":"Technical University of Berlin","acronym":"TU Berlin","id":"openorgs____::67d8be4e287c87e0d00a423dd923ecbe","pids":[{"scheme":"wikidata","value":"Q51985"},{"scheme":"Wikidata","value":"Q51985"},{"scheme":"fundref","value":"501100006764"},{"scheme":"ROR","value":"https://ror.org/03v4gjf40"},{"scheme":"GRID","value":"grid.6734.6"},{"scheme":"FundRef","value":"501100006764"},{"scheme":"OrgRef","value":"197203"},{"scheme":"OrgReg","value":"DE0029"},{"scheme":"PIC","value":"999986678"},{"scheme":"ISNI","value":"0000000122928254"}]},{"legalName":"Universiteit Twente, Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Mathematics and Computer Science (EEMCS), MESA+ Research Institute for Nanotechnology, NanoElectronics (NE)","acronym":"Universiteit Twente, Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Mathematics and Computer Science (EEMCS), MESA+ Research Institute for Nanotechnology, NanoElectronics (NE)","id":"pending_org_::2b259cfe3ac87655106086d7c1100b94","pids":null},{"legalName":"Universiteit Twente, Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Mathematics and Computer Science (EEMCS), Nano Electronics","acronym":"Universiteit Twente, Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Mathematics and Computer Science (EEMCS), Nano Electronics","id":"pending_org_::738944d96a0a4d9676c2ac6eb233a491","pids":null},{"legalName":"Technical University Eindhoven","acronym":"Technical University Eindhoven","id":"pending_org_::d26f2334d0ae1491f29bd4c0aa7a22c3","pids":null},{"legalName":"University of Münster","acronym":"WWU","id":"openorgs____::91ad861541a12e9823ad21841d47879d","pids":[{"scheme":"RRID","value":"RRID:SCR_011687"},{"scheme":"fundref","value":"501100004869"},{"scheme":"Wikidata","value":"Q168426"},{"scheme":"wikidata","value":"Q168426"},{"scheme":"OrgRef","value":"172246"},{"scheme":"PIC","value":"999853691"},{"scheme":"ISNI","value":"0000000121729288"},{"scheme":"fundref","value":"501100004870"},{"scheme":"ROR","value":"https://ror.org/00pd74e08"},{"scheme":"mag_id","value":"22465464"},{"scheme":"FundRef","value":"501100004870"},{"scheme":"FundRef","value":"501100004869"},{"scheme":"GRID","value":"grid.5949.1"}]},{"legalName":"Eindhoven University of Technology","acronym":"TU/e","id":"openorgs____::db787c50cf46f2b08e69f830e292e42d","pids":[{"scheme":"mag_id","value":"83019370"},{"scheme":"GRID","value":"grid.6852.9"},{"scheme":"OrgReg","value":"NL0004"},{"scheme":"FundRef","value":"501100003005"},{"scheme":"fundref","value":"501100003005"},{"scheme":"wikidata","value":"Q280824"},{"scheme":"RRID","value":"RRID:nlx_151954"},{"scheme":"ISNI","value":"0000000403988763"},{"scheme":"ROR","value":"https://ror.org/02c2kyt77"},{"scheme":"RRID","value":"RRID:SCR_003354"},{"scheme":"OrgRef","value":"9706"},{"scheme":"Wikidata","value":"Q280824"},{"scheme":"PIC","value":"999977269"}]},{"legalName":"University of Twente","acronym":"University of Twente","id":"openorgs____::604881198363fedbb5d5478f465305f2","pids":[{"scheme":"OrgRef","value":"101629"},{"scheme":"mag_id","value":"94624287"},{"scheme":"FundRef","value":"501100009404"},{"scheme":"fundref","value":"501100009404"},{"scheme":"PIC","value":"999900833"},{"scheme":"fundref","value":"501100001834"},{"scheme":"FundRef","value":"501100001834"},{"scheme":"wikidata","value":"Q1547084"},{"scheme":"PIC","value":"999660661"},{"scheme":"fundref","value":"501100007661"},{"scheme":"Wikidata","value":"Q1547084"},{"scheme":"ROR","value":"https://ror.org/006hf6230"},{"scheme":"OrgReg","value":"NL0005"},{"scheme":"GRID","value":"grid.6214.1"},{"scheme":"FundRef","value":"501100007661"},{"scheme":"ISNI","value":"0000000403998953"}]},{"legalName":"Universiteit Twente, Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Mathematics and Computer Science (EEMCS)","acronym":"Universiteit Twente, Faculty of Electrical Engineering, Mathematics and Computer Science (EEMCS)","id":"pending_org_::7a5b6c061d347e1efab98b01afb169e6","pids":null},{"legalName":"Universiteit Twente","acronym":"Universiteit Twente","id":"pending_org_::004728a3d788b6e7ee92ab7cf446b404","pids":null}],"communities":[{"code":"netherlands","label":"Netherlands Research Portal","provenance":null}],"collectedFrom":[{"key":"openaire____::9e3be59865b2c1c335d32dae2fe7b254","value":"Datacite"},{"key":"openaire____::081b82f96300b6a6e3d282bad31cb6e2","value":"Crossref"},{"key":"eurocrisdris::bc8e62f58a48e1f586b00703d8df2057","value":"Eindhoven University of Technology Research Portal"},{"key":"opendoar____::8b6dd7db9af49e67306feb59a8bdc52c","value":"Europe PubMed Central"},{"key":"opendoar____::6f4922f45568161a8cdf4ad2299f6d23","value":"arXiv.org e-Print Archive"},{"key":"eurocrisdris::5183b3da90ba1f87fd0673a4ca0bfa39","value":"University of Twente Research Information "},{"key":"opendoar____::eda80a3d5b344bc40f3bc04f65b7a357","value":"PubMed Central"}],"instances":[{"pids":[{"scheme":"doi","value":"10.1038/s41467-025-65155-7"}],"license":"CC BY","accessRight":{"code":"c_abf2","label":"OPEN","scheme":"http://vocabularies.coar-repositories.org/documentation/access_rights/","openAccessRoute":"gold"},"type":"Article","urls":["https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-025-65155-7"],"publicationDate":"2025-11-21","refereed":"peerReviewed","hostedBy":{"key":"openaire____::d9b7be21c63bb885703f2a24ff2938cf","value":"Nature Communications"},"collectedFrom":{"key":"openaire____::081b82f96300b6a6e3d282bad31cb6e2","value":"Crossref"}},{"pids":[{"scheme":"doi","value":"10.48550/arxiv.2105.11233"}],"license":"CC BY NC SA","type":"Article","urls":["https://dx.doi.org/10.48550/arxiv.2105.11233"],"publicationDate":"2021-01-01","refereed":"nonPeerReviewed","hostedBy":{"key":"openaire____::55045bd2a65019fd8e6741a755395c8c","value":"Unknown Repository"},"collectedFrom":{"key":"openaire____::9e3be59865b2c1c335d32dae2fe7b254","value":"Datacite"}},{"pids":[{"scheme":"pmid","value":"41271705"},{"scheme":"pmc","value":"PMC12639101"}],"alternateIdentifiers":[{"scheme":"doi","value":"10.1038/s41467-025-65155-7"}],"accessRight":{"code":"c_abf2","label":"OPEN","scheme":"http://vocabularies.coar-repositories.org/documentation/access_rights/","openAccessRoute":"gold"},"type":"Article","urls":["https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41271705"],"refereed":"nonPeerReviewed","hostedBy":{"key":"openaire____::d9b7be21c63bb885703f2a24ff2938cf","value":"Nature Communications"},"collectedFrom":{"key":"opendoar____::8b6dd7db9af49e67306feb59a8bdc52c","value":"Europe PubMed Central"}},{"alternateIdentifiers":[{"scheme":"doi","value":"10.1038/s41467-025-65155-7"}],"license":"CC BY","accessRight":{"code":"c_abf2","label":"OPEN","scheme":"http://vocabularies.coar-repositories.org/documentation/access_rights/","openAccessRoute":null},"type":"Article","urls":["https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-025-65155-7","https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12639101/","https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41271705/"],"publicationDate":"2025-11-21","refereed":"nonPeerReviewed","hostedBy":{"key":"opendoar____::eda80a3d5b344bc40f3bc04f65b7a357","value":"PubMed Central"},"collectedFrom":{"key":"opendoar____::eda80a3d5b344bc40f3bc04f65b7a357","value":"PubMed Central"}},{"pids":[{"scheme":"arXiv","value":"2105.11233"}],"accessRight":{"code":"c_abf2","label":"OPEN","scheme":"http://vocabularies.coar-repositories.org/documentation/access_rights/","openAccessRoute":null},"type":"Preprint","urls":["http://arxiv.org/abs/2105.11233"],"publicationDate":"2021-05-15","refereed":"nonPeerReviewed","hostedBy":{"key":"opendoar____::6f4922f45568161a8cdf4ad2299f6d23","value":"arXiv.org e-Print Archive"},"collectedFrom":{"key":"opendoar____::6f4922f45568161a8cdf4ad2299f6d23","value":"arXiv.org e-Print Archive"}},{"alternateIdentifiers":[{"scheme":"doi","value":"10.1038/s41467-025-65155-7"}],"license":"CC BY","accessRight":{"code":"c_abf2","label":"OPEN","scheme":"http://vocabularies.coar-repositories.org/documentation/access_rights/","openAccessRoute":"gold"},"type":"Article","urls":["https://research.tue.nl/en/publications/df37e49a-8cfc-4206-9cf4-ec2a5a4e8680","https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-025-65155-7"],"publicationDate":"2025-11-21","refereed":"nonPeerReviewed","hostedBy":{"key":"openaire____::d9b7be21c63bb885703f2a24ff2938cf","value":"Nature Communications"},"collectedFrom":{"key":"eurocrisdris::bc8e62f58a48e1f586b00703d8df2057","value":"Eindhoven University of Technology Research Portal"}},{"alternateIdentifiers":[{"scheme":"doi","value":"10.48550/arxiv.2105.11233"}],"license":"CC BY NC SA","accessRight":{"code":"c_abf2","label":"OPEN","scheme":"http://vocabularies.coar-repositories.org/documentation/access_rights/","openAccessRoute":null},"type":"Research","urls":["https://research.utwente.nl/en/publications/468078f0-c95d-4ab5-b62b-459cc25b5b9a","https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2105.11233"],"publicationDate":"2021-05-15","refereed":"nonPeerReviewed","hostedBy":{"key":"eurocrisdris::5183b3da90ba1f87fd0673a4ca0bfa39","value":"University of Twente Research Information "},"collectedFrom":{"key":"eurocrisdris::5183b3da90ba1f87fd0673a4ca0bfa39","value":"University of Twente Research Information "}},{"alternateIdentifiers":[{"scheme":"doi","value":"10.1038/s41467-025-65155-7"}],"license":"CC BY","accessRight":{"code":"c_abf2","label":"OPEN","scheme":"http://vocabularies.coar-repositories.org/documentation/access_rights/","openAccessRoute":"gold"},"type":"Article","urls":["https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-025-65155-7","https://research.utwente.nl/en/publications/b09c172e-87a3-408f-aeb2-f3519cac3ba6"],"publicationDate":"2025-12-01","refereed":"nonPeerReviewed","hostedBy":{"key":"openaire____::d9b7be21c63bb885703f2a24ff2938cf","value":"Nature Communications"},"collectedFrom":{"key":"eurocrisdris::5183b3da90ba1f87fd0673a4ca0bfa39","value":"University of Twente Research Information "}}],"links":[{"header":{"relationType":"resultProject","relationClass":"isProducedBy","relatedIdentifier":"dfgf________::1e5e62235d094afd01cd56e65112fc63","relatedRecordType":"project","relationProvenance":"sysimport:actionset","trust":"0.91"},"collectedfrom":[{"dsId":"openaire____::513d203da49f316ec241afa087643a02","dsName":"Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft"}],"projectTitle":"unidentified","code":"unidentified","funding":{"funder":{"id":"dfgf________::DFG","shortname":"DFG","name":"Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft","jurisdiction":{"code":"DE","label":"Germany"},"pid":null},"level0":{"id":null,"description":null,"name":null},"level1":{"id":null,"description":null,"name":null},"level2":{"id":null,"description":null,"name":null}}},{"header":{"relationType":"resultProject","relationClass":"isProducedBy","relatedIdentifier":"nwo_________::67563d4d3fff945e7e854b1b92050bdb","relatedRecordType":"project","relationProvenance":"iis","trust":"0.72"},"collectedfrom":[{"dsId":"openaire____::a4904a4b098aab846e966b7635bd8e01","dsName":"NWO - Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research"}],"projectTitle":"Evolutionary Computing in Nanomaterial Networks","code":"680-91-114","funding":{"funder":{"id":"nwo_________::NWO","shortname":"NWO","name":"Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research (NWO)","jurisdiction":{"code":"NL","label":"Netherlands"},"pid":null},"level0":{"id":null,"description":null,"name":null},"level1":{"id":null,"description":null,"name":null},"level2":{"id":null,"description":null,"name":null}},"startDate":"2017-12-01","endDate":"2022-05-31"},{"header":{"relationType":"resultProject","relationClass":"isProducedBy","relatedIdentifier":"nwo_________::2b348ef45c33b63733388ee1f906b8a2","relatedRecordType":"project","relationProvenance":"iis","trust":"0.72"},"collectedfrom":[{"dsId":"openaire____::a4904a4b098aab846e966b7635bd8e01","dsName":"NWO - Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research"}],"projectTitle":"Nanomaterial Networks for Artificial Intelligence in the Automotive Industry: NANO(AI)2","code":"16237","funding":{"funder":{"id":"nwo_________::NWO","shortname":"NWO","name":"Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research (NWO)","jurisdiction":{"code":"NL","label":"Netherlands"},"pid":null},"level0":{"id":null,"description":null,"name":null},"level1":{"id":null,"description":null,"name":null},"level2":{"id":null,"description":null,"name":null}},"startDate":"2018-09-01","endDate":"9999-12-31"},{"header":{"relationType":"resultProject","relationClass":"isProducedBy","relatedIdentifier":"corda_____he::850b2bd09d4e5fdac05a4164365ce14d","relatedRecordType":"project","relationProvenance":"iis","trust":"0.897"},"collectedfrom":[{"dsId":"openaire____::3f264f93cf3b0cfc4ede188a6300455c","dsName":"CORDA - COmmon Research DAta Warehouse - Horizon Europe"}],"projectTitle":"Hybrid electronic-photonic architectures for brain-inspired computing","code":"101046878","funding":{"funder":{"id":"ec__________::EC","shortname":"EC","name":"European Commission","jurisdiction":{"code":"EU","label":"European Union"},"pid":null},"level0":{"id":"ec__________::EC::HE","description":"Horizon Europe Framework Programme","name":"HE"},"level1":{"id":"ec__________::EC::HE::HORIZON-AG","description":"HORIZON Action Grant Budget-Based","name":"HORIZON-AG"},"level2":{"id":null,"description":null,"name":null}},"startDate":"2022-05-01","endDate":"2026-10-31"}],"otherTitles":null,"inDiamondJournal":false,"green":true,"isGreen":true,"isInDiamondJournal":false}